Consider our listings of homes for sale in Monticello and nearby areas.

You may filter our residential listings by specifying price ranges of houses, number of bedrooms and baths, as well as by the total square footage. Let your search for new homes for sale for Monticello begin here!

2184 SqFt House In Monticello
	2184 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $274,900 Homes for Sale Experience lake living from one of the best locations on Lake Shafer/Big Monon Bay. Enjoy the benefits of life on a bay. Bay living offers beautiful views, a quiet setting and safe swimming.......

1001 SqFt House In Monticello
	1001 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $134,900 Homes for Sale Completely remodeled and ready for your family! This 3 bedroom 2 bath home features many updates, including, new flooring throughout, furnace, C/A, plumbing, and new replacement windows, and a new......

1960 SqFt House In Freeman View
	1960 SqFt House In Freeman View Monticello, IN $389,900 Homes for Sale Stunning views from this beautiful Lake Freeman home! The interior offers 3 bedrooms plus a bonus room (4th bedroom) above the garage, 2.5 bathrooms, spacious great room with cathedral ceilings and......

3390 SqFt House In Monticello
	3390 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $309,900 Homes for Sale Fresh and ready for fun on the lake! This one has been renovated and offers 3/4 bedrooms, 3 full bathrooms, 3,390 sqft & sets on a main Lake Freeman lot with 84 ft of frontage. Breathtaking......

2368 SqFt House In Monticello
	2368 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $475,000 Homes for Sale SET YOUR SIGHTS AND SAILS FOR THIS FANTASTIC LAKE FREEMAN HOME ON PIRATES ROOST ROAD! You'll find all of your lake living needs in this beautiful property featuring: 1) the contemporary 4 Bed/2.5......

660 SqFt House In Monticello
	660 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $125,000 Homes for Sale Cozy Lake Freeman cottage featuring hardwood floors and lake views you can enjoy from your deck. 10 foot boat dock and community waterfront amenities. Also available to purchase is 11910 W Breezy......

2347 SqFt House In Monticello
	2347 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $349,900 Homes for Sale THE BEST OF BOTH WORLDS! You can have it all with this spacious Lake Shafer home which offers the unique opportunity to enjoy 'nice and new' interior living accommodations as well as the "classic......

Lakefront House With Fireplace
	Lakefront House With Fireplace Monticello, IN $419,900 Homes for Sale A very desirable Lake Freeman location! It's all about, Location, Location, Location! Well built, Custom home on main Lake Freeman with lots to offer! Overlooking lake views, this home offers 3......

1568 SqFt House In Tioga Park
	1568 SqFt House In Tioga Park Monticello, IN $249,900 Homes for Sale Rare find located on main Lake Freeman with concrete sea wall and enclosed boat house. Perfect summer get-away or full-time lake property. Hardwood floors and wood burning fireplace with unfinished......

2026 SqFt House In Colonial Oaks
	2026 SqFt House In Colonial Oaks Monticello, IN $339,900 Homes for Sale FOR THOSE WHO PREFER A PRIVATE PANORAMA, this is the place for you! This Main Lake Freeman home is perched upon 3 large waterfront lots offering sweeping lake views in all directions. And what......

3072 SqFt House In Monticello
	3072 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $389,900 Homes for Sale Wide open spaces, inside & out, with this nicely updated 3000+ sq ft home...oh, and BTW....THERE'S ALSO A LAKE INCLUDED!! You've got to check out this delightfully unique property situated on a......

960 SqFt House In Monticello
	960 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $94,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Welcome to this charming cottage overlooking main Lake Freeman! Home features a prime lake view with two very large shaded decks (1000+ sq ft.) facing water front. 3 bedrooms + loft for additional......

684 SqFt House In Monticello
	684 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $59,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Location...Location....and Cute as a button!! 2 bedroom 1 bath in a great neighborhood!! This home has charm from the moment you walk in the front door. The open concept living room and kitchen......

Updated 3-Bedroom House In Monticello
	Updated 3-Bedroom House In Monticello Monticello, IN $289,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! A fine way to spend your summer days on Lake Shafer! This one has a lot to offer! Outside features a double permanent boat lift, swim deck, steel sea wall, lakeside pavers patio, upper deck off of......

Private House With Fireplace
	Private House With Fireplace Monticello, IN $689,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Awesome entrance to this stunning Lake Freeman home with all of the amenities! Great room expands to an open kitchen, dining areas + double doors to the veranda with a great view! Expansive master......

1482 SqFt House In Monticello
	1482 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $304,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! You will have plenty of time for relaxing by the water from this LOW MAINTENANCE, updated lake home. A 1 story home that sets on a peaceful bay with beautiful views and a short boat ride out to the......

1092 SqFt House In Walnut Glen
	1092 SqFt House In Walnut Glen Monticello, IN $79,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Solid 3 bedroom 1 bath ranch with fenced in backyard not too far from downtown. Interior feature's open concept kitchen/living space with vaulted ceilings, built in shelving on island bar, spacious......

2167 SqFt House In Monticello
	2167 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $299,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! LAKE FREEMAN RETREAT! Treat yourself, friends & family to good times and lake fun with this multi-faceted 5 bedroom lake home ideal for extra guests. Main level offers an open living area for......

2876 SqFt House In Monticello
	2876 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $379,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Lake Shafer living doesn't get much better from this well maintained, spacious lake home. The roomy interior offers 2876 sqft, 4 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, cathedral ceilings, open concept floor plan,......

1078 SqFt House In Monticello
	1078 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $87,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Great Starter home or investment. Spacious 3 bedroom home, Beautiful hardwood floors, eat in kitchen and large laundry room with a bonus room. 2 car detached garage, metal roof and some new......

2052 SqFt House In Monticello
	2052 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $159,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! A 3 bedroom ranch-style home on a double-lot with a huge garage with work area on the Tippecanoe Country Club golf course? - Yes, please! Truly, at this price-point, this home will not last long!......

1800 SqFt House In Monticello
	1800 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $349,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! This home is located in a premier Lake Shafer location! It sets on one of the best lots out there offering approximately 150 ft of lake frontage & over a half acre in size. This lake home offers 3......

Updated Waterfront House
	Updated Waterfront House Monticello, IN $299,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Remarkable one owner (architect owner) year around home on Prime, Level, Main Lake Freeman! This home is "move-in" ready for Spring! Features an open floor plan of the kitchen, dining, and great......

1729 SqFt House In Monticello
	1729 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $249,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Spacious main Lake Shafer home! Outdoor living space that is made for entertaining on the lake. Lake side greets you with multi level decks, a permanent boat lift with a huge deck above, newer......

1104 SqFt House In Monticello
	1104 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $179,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Very nice home, on a corner lot with fantastic view of Lake Shafer. It has an easement that is approximately 70+ft at the water & road and 235 feet to the water. There are signs stating the private......

Updated 2-Bedroom House In Monticello
	Updated 2-Bedroom House In Monticello Monticello, IN $269,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Updated cottage setting on 70 ft of prime Lake Freeman frontage with spectacular views and incredible lake front improvements! The lakeside setting takes full advantage of the views from the double......

1830 SqFt House In Monticello
	1830 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $14,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! 3 bedroom home near the river. Many possibilities with this property. There is a large living room upstairs with brick fireplace, kitchen, bathroom, plus 1 bedroom. On Main floor there are two......

1961 SqFt House In Monticello
	1961 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $315,000 Homes for Sale  NEW! LAKEFRONT, LAND AND LODGING GALORE!! Rare find on Lake Shafer with nearly an acre of land and over 200 ft. of waterfront. The location just inside a small bay with main lake views and access at......

2934 SqFt House In Monticello
	2934 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $289,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Custom log cabin on the north end of Lake Freeman. Setting on 1/2 acre of land with 111 feet of water frontage this home offers 8 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, nearly 3000 sqft, main level master suite,......

2120 SqFt House In Monticello
	2120 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $399,990 Homes for Sale  NEW! FANTASTIC 2120 SQ FT LAKE SHAFER MAIN LAKE HOME WITH 50' WATERFRONT BUILT IN 2007, FEATURING 3 BEDROOMS, EACH WITH ITS OWN FULL BATHS. BEAUTIFUL KITCHEN WITH GRANITE COUNTER TOPS, STAINLESS STEEL......

2529 SqFt House In Monticello
	2529 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $74,500 Homes for Sale  NEW! This home has character galore from the plentiful windows for natural lighting to the mostly hardwood floors and natural woodwork. This home has a great covered front porch, 1 car detached garage......

1296 SqFt House In Monticello
	1296 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $105,000 Homes for Sale  NEW! Lake Living - Affordably! Large private yard, lake access, 3 bedroom, 1 bath ranch home with BIG porch! Kinetico water system. New furnace, AC and ductwork in 2017, new carpet in living and family......

612 SqFt House In Monticello
	612 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $35,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Nice cottage with view of Lake Schafer. Convenient to restaurant. Large living room. Storage shed and privacy fenced patio. Access to playground, volleyball courts, horseshoes and lakeside......

1527 SqFt House In Freeman View
	1527 SqFt House In Freeman View Monticello, IN $284,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! MOTIVATED Seller! Located in one of the nicest locations on Lake Freeman, this home offers a screened porch that runs the width of the home where you can enjoy fabulous panoramic lake views.......

2712 SqFt HOUSE In Monticello
	2712 SqFt HOUSE In Monticello Monticello, IN $175,000 Homes for Sale  NEW! Beautiful Brick two-story with 4 bedrooms and over 2700 sq ft of living area. Wonderful original wood work. Well maintained home with lots of improvements over the last several years including the......

Updated 4-Bedroom House In Hinterland Trails
	Updated 4-Bedroom House In Hinterland Trails Monticello, IN $189,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! A custom built home with Character. This 4 bed 2 bath home has a picturesque wooded setting & sits on over a 1/2 acre. Interior amenities include hardwood floors, updated bathrooms with tiled......

2988 SqFt House In Hickory Grove
	2988 SqFt House In Hickory Grove Monticello, IN $294,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! PRICE REDUCED!!! Best Views on Lake Freeman, Year-Round 4 bedroom Lake Home with over 2,900 sqft. of living area. Finished Loft above garage with bath has another 468 sqft. which could easily be......

1462 SqFt House In Monticello
	1462 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $274,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Ever dream of living in the proverbial house at the top of the lane - you know, the one with the bird's eye view of the rest of the neighborhood? Well, this IS that house . . . and the neighborhood......

2927 SqFt House In Monticello
	2927 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $319,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! Beautiful larger 2 story home located in Stoney Creek subdivision offering 4 bedrooms 3.5 baths with 2927 sq ft of finished living space. Open living area with cathedral ceilings and gas fireplace......

1100 SqFt House In Monticello
	1100 SqFt House In Monticello Monticello, IN $65,900 Homes for Sale  NEW! This home has been completely remodeled and is ready for your family. Tile and laminate floors, new windows, newer roof. Kitchen comes with all appliances and new cabinets. Separate utility room......